Same-Sex Couples & Child Custody

Serving the greater Columbus, Franklin county and Central Ohio areas.

Schedule a consultation

Same-Sex Couples and Child Custody in Columbus

Same-Sex Couples & Child Custody specialists with over 59 years of experience.

OHio Same-Sex Couples & Child Custody Lawyers

When the landmark Supreme Court decision legalized same-sex marriage in all 50 states, there were a number of states that were slow to implement changes to their legal code. Ohio is among those states. Basically, the Supreme Court ruling made it illegal for states to deny marriage licenses to same-sex couples. It also required states to recognize same-sex marriages that were issued in other states. It did not, however, require states to do anything beyond that.

Because Ohio was one of the states that outright banned same-sex couples from marrying, there has been a sluggish response by lawmakers to respond to the Supreme Court decision. To be sure, there are a number of ways that child custody can be affected by the legislative reality of the State of Ohio.

Understanding Your Options in Ohio While Pursuing a Same-Sex Divorce

All couples have three options when dissolving their marriage. Those are:

  • Contested divorce;
  • Mediation; and
  • Collaborative divorce.

Each of these is a distinct approach to dissolving a marriage.

  • In a contested divorce, the courts make all the decisions as the two sides argue for themselves and against each other to secure a favorable outcome.
  • Mediation involves one lawyer acting on behalf of both clients to come to an agreement that everyone can live with.
  • Collaborative divorce is somewhere in between. The two parties each have their own legal counsel but make a commitment to coming to a resolution that everyone can live with.

Both mediation and collaborative divorce allow couples to settle their disagreements without requiring court decrees on each issue. This includes custody arrangements.

The Complexities of Same-Sex Divorce in the State of Ohio

When same-sex marriage bans were outlawed, Ohio was one of 14 states that was forced to begin permitting same-sex couples to officially marry. This left Ohio behind when it came to managing same-sex divorces. While property issues were easy enough to navigate, custody battles were more complex. Under ideal circumstances, same-sex spouses can reach an agreement between each other that leaves the courts out of the process. When they can’t, the court has to step in and make the decision for them.

One factor that needs to be considered is the fact that only one of the spouses may have a biological connection to the child. There are other cases in which the child has been raised by the couple together. In these cases, one parent may have supplied genetic material or given birth to the baby, while the other cared for and supported the child throughout the marriage. In still other situations, neither parent may have supplied genetic material. The couple simply adopted the child.

Two of these instances are easy for the courts to determine. If one spouse brings a child in from another marriage, the court will rule that custody belongs to them. Stepparents only have rights in the case that they legally adopted the child. Nonetheless, this will only give them visitation rights and they will be forced to show that their right to access the child is critical for the child’s wellbeing.

In the case where neither parent supplied the child’s genetic material, the court can operate on the same basis that it decides cases when both parents supply genetic material.

The other two cases, however, are tricky.

Client Reviews

Had free consultation. Advice given was taken, and resulted in change of mind in the other/opposing party. We therefore did not need to retain. Should opposing party resume original opinion, we will retain.


I was in a terrible custody dispute with my ex. I was very upset and afraid of my ex. Rodd listened to everything I said and remembered everything I said. He was aggressive in court and used the information I gave him very well. We won the case and my ex has backed off.


I wanted an easy divorce from my wife. She wanted a fight. Rodd and I discussed fair terms for a dissolution. Because he was pro active and stayed on top of the case, my wife and I finally reached an agreement and had a dissolution. I highly recommend Rodd.


I hired Linda Lawrence because I have a business and I wanted to protect it in my divorce. Linda is top notch and knows about business finance and assets. I was able to keep my business and not have to pay my wife anything from it. Hire her.


I hired Linda Lawrence because I needed an aggressive attorney. Linda was able to stand up against the other attorney and was very aggressive in court. It was an expensive divorce case, but that was because the other attorney was very aggressive and Linda was very thorough. I had great results in my case and highly recommend Linda.


Contested Child Custody in Same-Sex Marriages

Courts will err on the principle that it’s better for a child to have both parents in their lives in some capacity. The question then becomes: to what extent do both parents have access. In cases where it can be shown that one parent is a danger to the children or otherwise unfit to engage in a co-custody arrangement, they will be denied access until they can prove otherwise.

The Lawrence Law Office has helped Columbus, OH same-sex couples draft legally binding co-custody agreements that have been drafted in good faith by each spouse. These agreements can grant visitation and access to adoptive parents. While custody agreements are binding, they can also be amended if circumstances change.

Contact a Same-Sex Couple Child Custody Attorney in Columbus

A dedicated Columbus same-sex couple child custody attorney at the Lawrence Law Office can help you and a same-sex partner come to a mutual agreement regarding custody of your child. If that attempt should fall apart, we can also advocate for your interests. Our custody agreements comply with Ohio family court guidelines and are designed to withstand legal challenges from extended family. Give us a call or contact us online and we can begin discussing your options for your same-sex child custody arrangement today.

Contact us

Lawrence Recent Blog Posts

January 21, 2020 in Paternity

Winning a Paternity Case in Ohio

Establishing paternity is critical to receiving child support payments or rights to visitation or custody. At Lawrence Law Office, we have represented men and women…
Read More
January 17, 2020 in child custody

High Income Child Custody Cases: What Makes Them Unique?

In many ways, child custody cases involving high-income parents are no different from any other custody dispute. A court will analyze what is in the…
Read More
December 23, 2019 in divorce

How To File For Divorce

A divorce commences with the filing of certain legal documents. For many people, the decision to file is a difficult one, and they need to…
Read More
December 23, 2019 in divorce, high asset divorce

Tips For An OH CEO Needing A Divorce

Divorce is different for everybody, and the best divorce attorneys understand that there is no “one size fits all” approach. Those men and women running…
Read More